Sectarianism doesn’t occur in a vacuum

This week we once again witnessed the pious wringing of hands, following the sentencing of two men for a brutal sectarian attack on a young woman, traumatising her and her child and forcing her to leave her Craigavon home,

The sentencing was followed by a chorus of righteous condemnation by the great and the good. While the vile actions of the criminals who were involved were rightly condemned many of the commentators bemoaning the horrific acts seemed oblivious to the reality of sectarianism, or perhaps it was a case of deliberately ignoring how the tribal interests in our society cosset and encourage sectarianism because it is to their advantage.

This same week analysis from the Department of Education suggests there are not enough places at integrated post-primary schools to meet demand in several areas of Northern Ireland. In effect, the provisions of the 2022 Act requiring the Department of Education to “encourage, facilitate and support” integrated education have been ignored.

Our society is more divided than it was at the time of the Belfast Agreement. Divided housing and segregated schooling, more walls dividing the community and the prioritisation of cultural identity, tribal symbols and community background over jobs, health and social progress together with sectarianism built into the very structures of government frame the political conditions in which sectarian acts take place.

Sectarianism is not the preserve of drunken individuals or extremist groups. It is not an aberration within a normal society. It is a sickness at the heart of our political system carefully fostered and sustained by a political narrative advanced by the tribal political parties to maintain a power base and endorsed by a compliant media.

It’s time to join the dots. Sectarian acts do not occur in a vacuum. Northern Ireland needs political change to eliminate sectarianism. The Workers Party has long advocated this. Only a commitment to working-class unity, secular, socialist and class-based politics offers a solution.

Covid Inquiry: exposing Northern Ireland’s sectarian landscape

The beginning of the Covid Inquiry hearings in Belfast have already begun to lay bare the deep malaise at the heart of Northern Ireland politics.

As the people of Northern Ireland suffered and died and as health workers risked their lives, the tribal forces fought it out at Stormont. 

The Inquiry has had difficulty securing the release of important material from the Executive Office.

The approach of the Ministers and senior civil servants, including deleted text and WhatsApp messages and missing phones, together with the revelation that Sinn Fein ministers and special advisers wiped their phones before returning them to Stormont, indicates the contempt in which ordinary working people are held.

Democratic accountability should be a crucial aspect of a political system which claims to represent its citizens and ensure their health and safety. Capitalist systems lack transparency and Northern Ireland is no different where tribal politicians who preserve that system prioritise their own interests and the interests of the capitalist class over public welfare and working peoples’ rights.

It is unlikely that this Inquiry will provide any real answers or effect any demonstrable change.

The sectarian political landscape in Northern Ireland and the unquestioning deference to capital over the rights and lives of workers and their families will remain until there is fundamental social, economic and political change and that will only come about when working people control their own destinies in a socialist society.

Nationalism: contemptuous, divisive and toxic

This week we witnessed two very similar examples of nationalism and the path that it inevitably follows. Both were in the outcomes of Coroner’s inquests: the first into the abduction and murder of Sean Brown in Bellaghy in 1997, the second into the sectarian slaughter of ten workmen at Kingsmill in 1974.

Too often ‘nationalism’ is accepted as a legitimate political opinion with equal standing and legitimacy alongside other ethical views. It is not.

Nationalism, British, Irish, and every other strain, is not only a backward political philosophy, it is a toxic one. It seeks to divide and exploit difference. It blames others and otherness. It is a political cancer that deliberately subverts progressive politics and attempts to thwart the development of class politics – often viciously and violently.

This week we saw two examples of nationalism’s contemptuous disregard for the families of victims of the ‘Troubles’.

The British government deliberately blocked access to files and information which could prove key to establishing the facts, the sequence of events and the nature of the relationships of all those involved in the abduction and murder of Sean Brown from Bellaghy. In refusing to release the required information, they cited reasons of ‘national security’, which really means, ‘we did what we did, the way we wanted to do it… and it’s none of your business’.

Nationalism ‘protects’ the ‘national interest’ even when that means withholding inquest details from families and loved ones and riding roughshod over legal practices.

We also witnessed the conclusion of the inquest into the murder of ten workmen in Kingsmill in January 1976.

It was nationalist gunmen that stopped, selected and slaughtered those ten workmen outside the Co. Armagh village. It was nationalism that refused to accept responsibility for what happened nor for the  pain and suffering inflicted on the families for  past 48 years. It was nationalism that turned its back on the inquest, offering neither apology nor information.

The next time we encounter nationalism, in whatever form, it’s worth reminding ourselves that it represents a political poison that stands in the way of uniting working people.

Progressive forces must strive at every turn to combat it, and we must never give an inch in our struggle against it. We have seen time and again where nationalism’s destructive path leads.

NEW OPPORTUNITIES OR THE  RETURN OF A COSY SECTARIAN CARVE -UP ?

If, amid all the media circus, midnight protesters, leaks claims and counter claims, the DUP do make an imminent return to Stormont, what will it actually mean for working people and their families?

Forgetting the rose-tinted glasses, let alone the orange and green ones, and all the hype about Northern Ireland Plc getting back to business, stability, certainty and the promises of pay settlements – the reality and the political future, particularly for working people, remains as grim as it’s ever been.

Others shape their worlds around tribal politics, community division and blatant sectarian trade-offs, all set against the backdrop of a ‘free-market’ economy which turns everything into commodities, profit and personal gain with the resultant hardship, misery and lost opportunities that implies for the vast majority of this and future generations.

If, as seems likely, there is a restoration of the Assembly and the formation of a new Executive then we are in for a prolonged period of sectarian triumphalism, tribalism, heightened community division, a lot of noise but very little social, political or economic progress. But for the Executive parties that’s never been what it’s about.

They can be relied upon to return to their tried, trusted and well-rehearsed routines of blaming ‘others’ for blocking progress, while building up their support base through fear, suspicion and community division: paying less than lip service to the needs of working people and their families. We know this because the track record is there for all to see.

Sinn Fein and the DUP have failed to deliver on the expectations evident at the time of the signing of the Good Friday Agreement – not by mis-management, but by design. Between them they have carved out and consolidated two sectarian power blocs.

How else can the deliberate side-lining of integrated education and integrated housing be explained? Why is it that we have more walls dividing the community today than we had twenty-five years ago? Why have cultural identity, tribal symbols and community background been given precedence over jobs, health and social progress?

The answer to all those questions is ‘because that’s how you build and maintain a sectarian power base’, and that is the strategy that both parties will continue to pursue when a new Executive is formed.

The challenge for socialists, trade unionists  and other progressive forces in our society is to call out, confront and overcome the corrupt and corrupting politics of these parties and to present a credible, class-based socialist alternative for workers, their families and their futures.

Talking to a Brick Wall

There are more ‘peace walls’ separating, dividing and isolating the community now than there were at the time the Good Friday Agreement was signed.

Minor tinkering with a gate here, a lower fence there, or even see through railings, can’t disguise the fact that what were once introduced as temporary structures have now become a permanent fixture not just in our towns and cities but in our psyche as well.

Today, there are more than 34 kilometres, or 21 miles, of walls, barriers and obstacles spread across Belfast. There are a total of 100 walls or barriers across Northern Ireland, 60 of them in the Belfast area. Many are in excess of 30 – 40 ft high.

These are almost exclusively in working class areas. But they are much more than physical barriers. They also consolidate the politics of separation, the divisions in our society and endow them with a sense of permanency and ‘normality’. They affect the way we think as well as the way we move about.

They affect the way we think as well as the way we move about.

Ten years ago, the Stormont Executive committed to removing all ‘peace walls’ by 2023.  It is now 2023. At the time they based their proposals on research which had found that 76% of the general population would like to see the walls come down now or in the near future and that 58% of people living next or close to the walls would like to see them come down now or sometime in the future. 

For many, the fact that the walls have not come down, and that the number has actually increased in that time, will further underline the determination of, in particular Sinn Fein and the DUP, to consolidate and develop tribal division in this society to strengthen their own constituencies.

Given the divisive and sectarian culture perpetuated by the main, and some smaller, political parties it is no surprise that the fears and tensions they stoke are reflected on the ground particularly in the immediate area of the ‘peace walls’. That same research back in 2013 also found that 69% of people living close to ‘peace walls’ maintained that the ‘peace walls’ were still necessary because of the potential for violence.

Those fears, those arguably exaggerated, cannot just be dismissed. There is a lot of work to be done in preparing the ground and changing the mindsets ahead of removing the walls. Very often people can contribute to a culture of fear and separation, but they are unlikely to have created it in the first place.

A lot to answer for

All those who promote and sustain a ‘two communities’ model, those who attempt to justify segregated education and segregated housing and those who prey on the fears of residents, have a lot to answer for. Not only are they maintaining physical barriers across the community, they are also poisoning the minds of generation after generation of young people forcing them to accept these artificial divisions as the norm.

There are always glimmers of hope, even after more than fifty years of barriers and separation. A group of young people, supported by the Empowering Young People Programme, has recently begun to lobby for extended opening hours for one of Belfast’s ‘interface gates’ as they try to hold on to and develop their new found relationships with each other. They should be encouraged and supported, but also made aware of the vested interests that will be stacked against them: political parties, paramilitaries, community workers and even many of the tourist guides whose livelihood depends so much on ‘Troubles Tours’.

Those young people are right. There should be unhindered access across the city and throughout Northern Ireland for all citizens in all areas. To do otherwise makes  no sense.

Big and Bold Steps

Piecemeal proposals and cosmetic campaigns can do more to validate the walls than vanquish them. If we are to make progress then the vested interests need to be exposed and challenged, their arguments laid bare for the divisive, and often sectarian, invective that it is. The only steps worth taking are the big and bold ones.

The enemy of big change is small change, and small change is not enough.

Brick Walls, Sectarianism and Citizenship

Political, social and economic life here has come to an almost complete stop.

Twenty-five years after the signing of the Good Friday Agreement and its overwhelming endorsement by the vast majority of people on this island we are left facing a brick wall with little, if any, prospect of progress.

The Agreement offered new hope and optimism, but the vicious and deadly battles between British and Irish nationalism, played out on our streets for thirty years, is now being replicated in Stormont and the Assembly, characterised by the all too familiar debasements of negativity, tribal confrontation and, sectarianism.

Perhaps now is the time to review our relationships and seek a way out of the political cul-de-sac we have been forced down by Sinn Fein and the DUP.

More than fifty years ago thousands of people in Northern Ireland took to the streets campaigning for a better, more equitable, society. Their demands were not devalued by issues of cultural identity, community background or tribal loyalties.

Relationships

Perhaps now is the time to review our relationships and seek a way out of the political cul-de-sac we have been forced down by Sinn Fein and the DUP.

If there is no way through the wall then we must go around it. Not as Catholics, or Protestants, not as unionists or nationalists. Not as British, Irish, Northern Irish or any other origin. Those of us who believe that better is possible and who refuse to sit and wallow in the sectarian status quo need a basis, a platform, on which to progress and to move society forward.

The concept of socialist citizenship, based on class politics, working class unity and solidarity, would help to re-define our relationships and responsibilities to each other and to the institutions of government through clear and guaranteed relationships underpinned by a Bill of Rights.

Tribal positions

Of course, there will be those who will not want to avail of such an opportunity. There will be those who will actively oppose it in an attempt to tie the rest of us into their tribal positions. But the choice is there for those of us who want to explore the possibilities offered on the other side of the political brick wall that we have been facing for the last twenty-five years. Citizenship offers a way forward.

Unless we re-calibrate our relationships and understanding of each other we, and our children, will be facing this same brick wall in twenty-five and fifty-years time.

The Sinn Fein / DUP strategy has been to manipulate and manage sectarianism, rather than seeking to eradicate it. The failure to tackle sectarianism therefore has nullified much of the good intent contained within the God Friday Agreement.

Tackling sectarianism

We cannot afford to do nothing and hope that time alone will resolve this issue. Unless, and until, the issue of sectarianism is comprehensively tackled, we will never realise the vision of a new society which leaves behind the out-dated attitudes and prejudices which have been the cause of so much misery and despair.

Those of us who oppose sectarianism must organise as strongly and as stubbornly as those who promote and profit from it. The concept of socialist citizenship gives us that commonality and base camp from which to progress

Socialist citizenship is not a silver bullet. It is not a quick fix panacea.

However, it could form the basis for a constructive, respectful and forward looking society, as an alternative to backward, parochial ethnocentricity. Neither Sinn Fein nor the DUP can hold out that hope

Socialists Must Stand Up

Workers Party President, Cllr Ted Tynan has called for ‘socialists, trade unionists and anti-sectarian forces’ to challenge and oppose what he described as the “on going and ill-conceived clamour for a Border Poll”.

His remarks come ahead of this weekend’s ‘Ireland’s Future’ conference in Dublin.

“It is important” he said, “that the nature and intent of this campaign is exposed for the shallow, sectarian scam that it is, and that Ireland’s progressive forces continue to build the basis of working-class unity as the only secure foundation for the people of this island and beyond”

Mood music and rhetoric

Cllr Tynan said, “the mood music and the rhetoric about ‘historic destinies’ and a ‘new Ireland’ belie the character, track record and intentions of the key players. History repeats itself.  We’ve been here before and so have many other countries. We’re not as special as some would have us believe. The nationalist middle classes, north and south, are wrapped confidently in the green flag and have their sights sets on a bespoke future, that holds little for working people and their families”.

“Calls for a Border Poll are divisive and unnecessary. Increasingly, almost every issue in this country is viewed myopically through sectarian glasses with orange and green lenses.

Manufactured urgency

“So it is with the growing clamour for a Border Poll, driven largely by Sinn Fein, and now supported by a number of new organisations, some academics, a variety of media commentators and other nationalist parties, north and south, desperate not to be left behind this wave of manufactured urgency.

“The Ireland’s Future’ camp is no place for socialists or for those claiming to be on the left. Some, however, attempt to justify their involvement. Whatever the political contortions required to clear their consciences some basic and distasteful realities remain. 

Cultural identity politics

The campaign for a Border Poll is premised on little more than a religious headcount with the implicit assumption that ‘catholic equals united Ireland’ and ‘protestant equals union with Britain’.

This is the worst form of cultural identity politics and ultimately it is built on foundations of sand. Worse still, the dangers of pressing a divisive nationalist agenda in a community which is already deeply divided risks being characterised as a sectarian crusade.”, said Cllr Tynan

“Ireland is not Scotland”, Cllr. Tynan said. “In the absence of working-class unity there is a real risk and potential for sectarian violence in the lead up to and in the aftermath of a Border Poll – irrespective of the outcome”.

Working class unity

“The Workers Party has always pursued and remains committed to the objective of a unitary socialist state on this island. We have long recognised that is a long term and onerous project and it can only be built on working class unity rather than the territorial unity of a united capitalist Ireland which offers no solution to the urgent problems facing working people, north and south.

 “It is a project constantly frustrated by those who see their privileged positions threatened by that outcome, but it is also thwarted by those who happily and arrogantly dismiss and disregard the million people on this island who don’t want to be forced into a “united” Ireland against their wishes”, Cllr. Tynan said.

Absolute and non-negotiable

The unity of the working class and a fundamental transformation of our social, political and economic system remain an absolute and non-negotiable prelude to the creation of a single unitary state. Simply, hoisting the green flag will not end the misery, exploitation and oppression of workers and their families in Dublin or in Belfast”, Cllr Tynan concluded.

Unacceptable Levels

In 1971, the then Secretary of State for Northern Ireland Reggie Maudling talked about “an acceptable level of violence”. Fifty years later we are wallowing in what could be justifiably described as ‘an acceptable level of sectarianism’.

Recent events have once again highlighted the depths to which this society has sunk.

We have witnessed young people inanely chanting about and glorifying three decades of murder, sectarianism and terror, that they fortunately did not have to live through, yet more bonfires burning images and symbols designed to heighten community divisions, the grossly insensitive and provocative display of Parachute regiment flags in Derry and, perhaps the most telling of all, the vitriolic, unapologetic and tribal reactions on social media, radio phone in programmes and from elected representatives and commentators.

Offensive and sectarian acts are not only being justified, they are being normalised through a narrative which argues that ‘they do this and we do that – so that’s alright’.

All sorts of cover is offered as justification for the vilest and most divisive behaviour. It is defended as ‘culture’, it is minimalised in an attempt to make it insignificant, it is boasted as a ‘right’.  It is shamelessly and brazenly defended without apology or concern. These are the depths to which we have sunk.

Such is the polarisation and division in this society that it now seems impossible to call out one sectarian act without reference to another, often unrelated, incident by way of justification. 

The levels of vitriol and invective, particularly on social media, evidences the arrogance, the confidence and the assuredness of the perpetrators, in what amounts to tribal warfare.

Arguably, we have reached what many view as ‘an acceptable level of sectarianism’, as any pretence at uniting the community is swept aside and battle lines are drawn between competing nationalisms, British and Irish.

All the while, the major political parties happily reap what they have sown, retaining their positions of power and privilege at the expense of working-class people including, ironically, those who act out the sectarian script on their behalf.

That this is happening during one of the worst a cost-of-living crisis in recent memory makes it all the more frustrating for those on the political left who seek unity amongst workers, an end to sectarianism and a radical change in the structure of society.

History will not look favourably on our condemnations alone if we do not seek ways to build a bulwark against the tribalism of our times.

Bad moon rising?

The warning signs are already clear, the well-rehearsed arguments are converging and the battle lines have been drawn. We are facing a very difficult, and potentially very dangerous 12 month period.

Politics in Northern Ireland are dominated and divided by nationalism: pro-British and pro-Irish versions: both are toxic and both are destructive

In recent days we have seen protocols, polls and policing, used to fuel claim and counter claim, building on existing division and further polarising and dividing the community.

The pro-British nationalism of the DUP, and others, using ill thought out, but confrontational, strategies to hype up the threat to the union, and the appalling, unapologetic arrogance and contempt of Sinn Fein, have set the ground rules for the coming months and for the run in to next year’s Assembly elections.

We are now beginning to see the outworking of those strategies taking shape in the form of  riots and street violence. The fear must be that worse is yet to come.

In the face of the basest forms of tribal politics, and the potential threat they pose, the need for a united, coherent and focussed working class response has never been more urgent.

In a little over twelve months’ time there will be an Assembly election. Much of the recent tribalism, political posturing and grandstanding is aimed at laying the groundwork for that election campaign. When that spills over into the streets in the form of riots, disturbances and attacks, as we are already witnessing, it will not be by accident but by deliberate design.

The nationalism of the DUP, Sinn Fein and others demands that the tribal stakes are constantly raised and raised again. If that means some teenagers and young people from working class communities end up in prison, injured or worse then so be it. Of course, both parties will be the first to condemn the violence, the bloodshed and the community strife, while in the same breath calculating how much they had gained from it and how much further they need to go.

The only response to this deadly and downward nationalist spiral is the collective voice and action of a united working class, committed to and focused on a political and social agenda which will drive a progressive wedge into the heart of political life here.

That measure must involve trade unionists, working people, progressive and anti-sectarian elements, principled parties of the left and, importantly, forward thinking members of the media and other professions. It is not too late to openly reject the politics and consequences of nationalism. Nor is it too late to call them out. However, the day for howling at the moon has long gone.

Tunnel Vision

It’s been said before, but it bears repeating. Almost all of public life in Northern Ireland is assessed and evaluated in terms of Orange or Green. Or is that an exaggeration and an unfair generalisation? – asks Workers Party South Belfast representative, Patrick Lynn

It’s certainly true of education. We maintain and sustain two entirely separate systems from primary through to secondary level. It’s also true of housing: 90% plus of public housing developments are exclusively either catholic or protestant.  Community development projects are designed and funded on the “two communities” model.

Even what should be strategic infrastructure developments are plagued by the perceptions that “they” might be getting more out of it that “us”. Factor in sport and culture as further examples and its almost a full house

The hysterical reactions to the announcement of a feasibility study into a permanent link with Scotland is further proof of how ingrained and accepted sectarianism has become. Whether a bridge or other form of link across the Irish Sea is a good thing or not is irrelevant in the face of the reaction it has generated.   

The source of both the support and of the objections is largely predictable, and almost guaranteed. Probably the largest, and certainly the most expensive, proposal since the HS2 rail link and by far the biggest construction project effecting both Northern Ireland and the Republic has been reduced to an argument over whether it is being used to strengthen the Union or a device to fend off a united Ireland. It is tunnel vision at its worst.

Had the proposal come from Dublin the arguments would simply have been reversed. Much of the opposition is based on a growing and emboldened anti-British sentiment on this island. Much of the support is an almost knee jerk reaction to the opposition.

It is of course easy to point the finger exclusively at the man and woman in the street and blame then for all our ills, but that would be to let the architects of tunnel vision off the hook.

Sectarianism is the life blood of the main political parties here. They would deny that, but it’s hard to refute. Their electoral appeal is fashioned on it, their votes are headcounts based on it and their politics are tribal tirades designed to sustain it. They are not alone. They are joined and legitimised by media commentators many of whom extend influence without responsibility. Many of them find regular outlets in our newspapers, television and radio programmes.

Collectively they fulfil a number of important tasks in Northern Ireland life. They articulate and sustain division. They would deny it but, again, it is hard to refute. They perpetuate fear of the ‘other’ and they divert our attention away from reality.  Most importantly of all they provide a smokescreen – in orange and green – behind which lies the real class nature of this society.

The economic and social system we live under is based on the accumulation of capital, relentless production and the unending pursuit of profit.  The main political parties here, in the UK and in the Republic of Ireland support and manage that system to the detriment of ordinary working people.  Its not really that complicated. That’s how it works.

One of the many devices used to make that process easier is to create and sustain division. Sometimes it’s based on ethnicity, sometimes it’s based on gender and sometimes it’s based on cultural differences – but always it’s based on class. In Northern Ireland our local variation is religion and community background – but the purpose and the effects are the same.

“While the political parties and the tribal spokespeople continue to deride or admire the latest project through sectarian lenses, they dig this society deeper into the mire than any tunnel could and they build no bridges, but they successfully keep the spotlight off the class nature of our society and the misery, deprivation and dead-end despair that it brings”, Patrick concluded